Highlights

Research Training Program
VIRTUAL POSTER SESSION
2003


Looking South of Iceland Through Volcanic Glasses

Brittany Meagher
Research Training Program, 2003



Vitrual Poster Session
MENU

Looking South of Iceland through Volcanic Glasses


Geologic hot spots are places where a column of upwelling hot rock, known as a plume, rises from deep in the mantle toward the Earth's surface. When a hot spot occurs in the ocean, it builds shield volcanoes like the Hawaiian Islands. These islands are constructed on the deep ocean floor and build up until plate movement has shifted the volcano off of the hot spot. A new volcano starts forming only a little distance from the old now dying volcano.

Although most Hot Spots form in the center of a tectonic plate, they can also occur along mid-ocean ridges. Iceland is an example of such a hot spot. At a mid-ocean ridge the oceanic crust is spreading apart allowing magma to come to the surface. This upwelling of magma leads to new crust being formed. Iceland sits astride the Mid-Atlantic ridge, making a place where large amounts of magma has erupted to build the volcanic structure above sea level.


ABSTRACT

Iceland has been hypothesized to not only be a hot spot but also a wet spot. This would mean that water contents of Mid Ocean Ridge Basalts (MORBs) would increase as Iceland is approached along the Mid-Atlantic Ridge from the south. To test this hypothesis twenty-eight samples were obtained from the Smithsonian Sea-Floor Glass Collection. The majority of these samples run along the Reykjanes Ridge just south of Iceland. These samples were analyzed for H2O using Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy.

Upon analyzing the results of this method, it was found that H2O increases as Iceland is approached from the South along the Reykjanes Ridge. Similar increases can also be seen in the abundances of K2O and P2O5. This is what was expected to be found since K (potassium), H (hydrogen), and P (phosphorus) are all incompatible elements in basaltic systems.

One way to explain this increase in incompatible elements is to argue that there is a lower percent of melting happening beneath Iceland compared to the southern Reykjanes Ridge. However, since Iceland is known to be a very active hot spot, where anomalously large volumes of magma have erupted, the idea of lowering the percent melting to provide an explanation for the abundance of incompatible elements does not make sense. The logical alternative explanation is that the Icelandic hot spot must come from an enriched mantle source, in turn showing that Iceland is indeed not only a hot spot but also a wet spot.


INTRODUCTION

The Mid-Atlantic Ridge runs southward through Iceland down to Antarctica, splitting the Atlantic Ocean in two. This ridge is one of the best-known examples of a divergent-plate boundary. In the North Atlantic it separates the North American Plate from the Eurasian Plate, and in the South Atlantic it separates the South American Plate from the African Plate. In the 1950s, the ridge was discovered, leading to the idea of sea-floor spreading, and to the acceptance of Wegener’s theory continental drift.

The Reykjanes Ridge is located southwest of Iceland along the Mid-Atlantic Ridge. It is approximately 1,100 km long, extending between Iceland and the Bight fracture zone. In a paper published in Earth and Planetary Science Letters, Nichols stated “the water content increases northwards along the Reykjanes Ridge towards Iceland”(Nichols et al. 2002). This led him to believe that Iceland “does indeed appear to be a wet spot compared to the southern end of the Reykajanes Ridge”(Nichols et al. 2002). We seek to confirm this recently proposed hypothesis that the Iceland hot spot is also a wet spot.


Samples Studied

  • For this research twenty-eight glass samples were obtained from the Smithsonian Sea-Floor Glass Collection. The samples for this project were randomly selected from groups based on locality.
  • Of the twenty-eight samples, seven were located south of the Reykjanes Ridge, fifteen were from the Ridge, and the remaining six were located on the Mid-Atlantic ridge just north of Iceland.
  • All of the samples selected had been analyzed for major element abundances by electron microprobe and have known latitude, longitude, and depth information.


DISCUSSION

 
H (hydrogen) as an Incompatible Element:
 
Obvious peaks in K2O, P2O5, AND H2O concentrations around 62o latitude were found. Figures 2a and 3a have many more data points because they use the entire data for this area from the Smithsonian Sea-Floor Glass Collection. Since the graphs of K2O and P2O5 vs. latitude are almost identical, these two components are clearly related to one another. Both K2O and P2O5 are thought to be incompatible elements in basaltic magma systems.

Incompatible elements are those elements that are not significantly incorporated in the minerals present in a magmatic system. Instead these elements are concentrated in the melt (glass). For basaltic systems K (potassium), P (phosphorus), and H (hydrogen) are all strongly incompatible. This common incompatibility is the reason that K2O, P2O5, and H2O are expected to behave similarly.
 
No Control by Saturation
 
The data shows an increase in H2O as Iceland is approached from the south, moving north along the Reykjanes Ridge. This trend parallels those for K2O and P2O5 in the same samples. This demonstrates that the abundance of H2O is not constrained by saturation in the melt controlled by the weight of the overlying column of seawater. If it was, the H2O content would increase with greater sample depth. However here we find the opposite. As the waters get shallower towards Iceland the H2O content increases. This shows that water plays a significant role in the production of melts near Iceland.
 
Causes of Incompatible Element Enrichment in Icelandic Basalts
 
The similarity of behavior for H2O, K2O, and P2O5 shows that there is probably an increase in their abundances in the mantle source region of the basalts as Iceland is approached. However, these commonalities could also be accounted for by a lower percent of melting. If the percent melting in decreased, then this will in turn increase the amount of K2O, P2O5, and H2O in the melt. This however, is the conundrum of a hot spot. The excess volume of melt produced around Iceland, to build the massive volcanic island up from the sea floor implies a higher percent melting, in conflict with this interpretation. This is the reason that it is believed that the Icelandic hot spot must come from an enriched mantle source.

It is interesting to note that on the plots of K2O and P2O5 in figures 2a and 3a. There is a definite drop off in the contents of K2O and P2O5 north of Iceland. However, proceeding farther north along the Mid-Atlantic Ridge the contents tend to increase. This trend peaks sharply around the Jan Mayen hot spot (71o N latitude), which also appears to have an enriched source.


CONCLUSIONS

Total water contents were analyzed by Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy in twenty-eight samples of quenched pillow basalts from the Mid- Atlantic Ridge, obtained from the Smithsonian Sea-Floor Glass Collection. The samples show an increase in the amount of H2O as Iceland was approached from the south. This increase in H2O parallels previously known trends for K2O and P2O5. H, K, and P are all considered to be incompatible elements in basaltic systems and all of them were found to have the same increasing trend approaching Iceland.

Since Iceland is known to be a very active hot spot, the idea of lowering the percent melting to provide an explanation for the great abundance of incompatible elements does not make sense. This leaves the idea that the melt comes from an enriched mantle source as the only other explanation for this high level of incompatible elements coupled with high magma-production rate.


Acknowledgements

I would like to thank Jim Luhr, Tim O’Hearn, Bill Melson, and the whole Mineral Sciences Department at Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History. I would also like to thank the National Science Foundation for their generous donation to the Research Training Program.

 


Want to ask a question? Visit the Message Board

Virtual Poster Session Message Board
Here you can to read other messages and comments, post your own message or comment, and then receive feedback from the RTP participants.

Research Training Program
Schedule of Events  |  Poster  |  Program Summary
Student Abstracts
  |  Photo Gallery
Virtual Poster Session


The information presented here represents preliminary research as the result of ten-weeks of investigation in-residence at the National Museum of Natural History. This is not an official publication of the information.

As preliminary information, results and/or findings should not be cited as part of conclusive work. Please contact the authors first if you wish to utilize the information presented here.

 

Research from
Systematic Biology

BOTANY

Abigail Moore
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"The delimitation of Viguiera pazensi and V. procumbens (Asteraceae)"

Poster
Abstract / Summary
Letter

BOTANY

Michael Marchizza
Research Experiences for Teachers

"Genetic Variation In Genus Magnolia Using Chloroplast Gene Spacer Sequences"

Poster
Abstract
/ Summary
Letter

ENTOMOLOGY

Stephanie Johnson
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Cyphomyrmex longiscapus Weber one fungus ant species or many?"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ENTOMOLOGY

Sebastian Patino

Research Assistantships for Minority High School Students

"Databasing Moth Genitalia Facts"

Poster
Abstract / Summary
Letter

VERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY
FISHES

Amanda Cass
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"A preliminary survey of the dorsal gill arches of flatfishes (Pleuronectiformes) and an examination of potential phylogenetic consequences"

Poster
Abstract / Summary
Letter

VERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY
MAMMALS

Miguel Fernandez
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Testing a predictive model of amphibian distributions for Bolivia"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

VERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY
AMPHIBIANS & REPTILES


Raul Diaz
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Phylogenetic relationships among corytophanine iguanid lizards inferred from morphological characters"

Poster
Abstract
/ Summary

Letter

VERTEBRATE ZOOLOGY
BIRDS


Hilary Turner
"Ornithology: A Museum Perspective"

Poster

Research from
Paleobiology

PALEOBIOLOGY

Nancy Price
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Planktonic Foraminiferal Turnover and Paleoceanographic Change Across the Aptian-Albian Boundary in the Subtropical North Atlantic"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

PALEOBIOLOGY

Clemontene Rountree
Research Experiences for Teachers

"Ecology and biodiversity of the Montastraea “annularis” reef coral species complex "

Poster
Abstract / Summary
Letter

Research from
Mineral Sciences

MINERAL SCIENCE & GEOLOGY

Jocelynn Johnson
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"A Microchemical Investigation of Fossilized Wood: Biological Preservation and the Influence of Mineralization"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

MINERAL SCIENCE & GEOLOGY

Jennifer Maloney
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Cathodoluminescence Study of Feldspars from the Black Mountain Pegmatite, Maine"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

MINERAL SCIENCES & GEOLOGY

Brittany Meagher
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Volatiles in Sea-Floor Volcanic Glasses South of Iceland"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

Research from
Anthropology

ANTHROPOLOGY

Skye Chang
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Lost and Found: Forensic Analysis of an 1862 Cast Iron Coffin"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY

Dalia Palchik
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"A Short Case Study of Key Issues Surrounding Gender and Economics in Mali as Observed Through the 2003 Smithsonian Folklife Festival"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY

Danielle Royer
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"The Spatial Distribution of Early Human Tool-Making Activities One Million Years Ago in the Southern Rift Valley of Kenya"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY

Toccarra Thomas
Research Experiences for Undergraduates

"Musicianship in Modern Mali: social and political influences"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY

Elizabeth Bollwerk
Notre Dame Internship Program in Anthropology

"Picking Out the Pueblos: A Documentation Investigation"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY

Lesley Gregoricka
Notre Dame Internship Program in Anthropology

"CSI Sheep: Skeletal Reconstruction and Demographic Analysis"

Poster
Abstract / Summary

Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY

Nicole Whiteclay
Research Assistantships for Minority High School Students

"Theoretical Documentation of Pretty Eagle"

Poster
Abstract / Summary
Letter

ANTHROPOLOGY


Suzanne Ii
Minority Internship Program

"Sexual Dimorphism of the Distal Humerus"

Poster

ANTHROPOLOGY


Nicole Truesdell
Minority Internship Program

"Nonmetric Racing of the Skull in Blacks and Whites"

Poster

EDUCATION

Soo-Yin Lim-Thompson

Research Opportunities Award

"Smithsonian Outreach: Science Resources for Teachers"

Poster
Abstract / Summary
Letter

More RTP Class of '03 Links


Research Abstract
Virtual Poster
Project Summary
Letter of Gratitude

Key Links to RTP Web Pages

Information   |   Highlights   |   Alumni Pages
 Application Procedure
   |   Requirements   |   Application Status
Application Form   |   Cover Letter Form   |   Letter of Recommendation Form
   |   Advisor List



  NMNH Home   |  What's New ?   |  Calendar of Events   |  Information Desk   |  Search